Automation 2 min read
Zapier, Make or Power Automate: which should a small business use?
An honest comparison of the three automation tools small businesses ask us about most, with what each is good at, what it costs, and when you need none of them.
We get asked this a lot, usually by someone who has already tried one of them at eleven o'clock at night. The honest answer is that all three are good, they suit different situations, and the tool matters far less than the process you point it at.
Zapier
The easiest to start with and the one with the most connections to other software. If you want an enquiry from your website to appear in your CRM and your inbox, Zapier will do it in twenty minutes. It gets expensive as the number of tasks grows, and complicated workflows with branches and loops become hard to follow.
Best for: simple, high-value connections between popular tools, built quickly.
Make
More visual, more powerful, and cheaper per task than Zapier. It handles branching, loops and data transformation well, which makes it a good fit for a process with a few decisions in it. It takes a little longer to learn and the visual canvas can get crowded.
Best for: processes with some logic in them, where you want to see the whole flow on one screen.
Power Automate
Microsoft's tool, and if your business runs on Microsoft 365 it is often already included in what you pay. It is excellent at anything involving Outlook, Teams, SharePoint, Excel and Dynamics, and it can run on a desktop to drive older software that has no proper connection. Outside the Microsoft world it is clunkier than the other two.
Best for: Microsoft-based businesses, approvals, and anything that touches SharePoint or Teams.
When you need none of them
If the two systems you want to connect already talk to each other (Xero and many CRMs, for example), use the built-in connection. If the job needs to run thousands of times a day, or involves sensitive data you would rather keep in-house, a small purpose-built integration is cheaper and more reliable than any of the three.
What matters more than the tool
Three things. Whether the process has been simplified first, so you are not automating steps that should not exist. Whether someone in your business can see what the automation does and change it, so you are not stuck with whoever built it. And whether it has monitoring, so you find out when it stops before your customers do.
We build on all three tools and on none of them, depending on the job. If you would like a recommendation for your situation, book a free call.